We have stayed at The Mountaineer many times over the past few years, and always enjoy it. The sites are good, each has a picnic table, fire ring, and most have a small slab to set out chairs, etc on. The park is under a hugh canopy of trees and is located on the Little River. You can walk along the path by the river or sit on a bench and read if you want. The owners Bob & Barb Hurst are very family oriented and also love animals. They are some of the nicest people you will every meet. They do believe in quiet time, but most evenings there is a pit fire up front(when it's cool enough) and pickin' and singin'. They believe in a clean campground and the bathhouse is among th cleanest I've ever been in. The campground is located close to Cades Cove and Maryville is not too far in the other direction. There is tubing, horseback riding, biking and hiking. These are all within a mile or two of the CG. We have reservations for October this year with the 7 couples that we camp with every year. This will be our 2nd time as a group to stay at The Mountaineer and My DH & I were just there at Easter. Hope this helps, can't tell you about the other one you mentioned as we have never stayed there. Happy Camping! Anne